Whitman Expo
Numismaster.com ceased operations on July 31, leaving paid digital subscribers scrambling to pursue other options for their numismatic information.
Thank you to our sponsors!
Go check them out!
The 1916 proof Buffalo nickel has a tiny mintage of only 600 pieces, the lowest of the series. The majority of 1916 proofs are found in the PR64-66 range, though several dozen have been certified by PCGS and NGC in PR67. Both firms have certified fewer than a combined dozen as PR68s. The 1916 proof Buffalo nickels were the last regular-issue proofs for the series until 1936, when the US Mint revived its proof coin program after a 20-year hiatus.
Obverse Description
James Earle Fraser's famous and simple design depicts a Native American chief with the word LIBERTY from 1-2 o'clock. The date is placed on the lower left of the chieftain's bust.
Reverse Description
A full portrait of the bison, Black Diamond, with the words UNITED STATES oF AMERICA at the top periphery with the motto E PLURIBUS UNUM just underneath. The denomination FIVE CENTS is spelled out at the bottom. For the Type 1, the denomination is embossed on a flat surface.
Catalog Information
GSID:
3154
Designer:
James Earle Fraser
Obverse Designer:
James Earle Fraser
Obverse Lettering:
LIBERTY, 1916
Reverse Designer:
James Earle Fraser
Reverse Lettering:
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, E PLURIBUS UNUM, FIVE CENTS
Weight (gr):
5 gr
Weight (oz):
0.1608 oz
Strike Type:
Proof
Diameter:
21.2
Coin Shape:
Round
Edge:
Plain
Variety:
Matte Finish
Coin Date:
1916
Denomination:
5c
Designation:
PR
Mint Location:
Philadelphia
Mintage:
600
Coinage Type:
Buffalo nickel
Coinage Years:
1913-1938
Composition:
75% copper; 25% nickel
PCGS #:
3993
Send Catalog Feedback
To: editor@greysheet.com
Subject: I would like to contribute catalog info to CDN for 1916 5c Matte Finish PR
Body: Referring page: https://www2.greysheet.com/prices/item/1916-five-cents-buffalo-nickel-proof/gsid/3154 GSID: 3154 Title: 1916 5c Matte Finish PR
Subscribe to View
View more data, info, and visualizations. Get access to retail and wholesale pricing as well as auction data.
Coin Value History
1916 5c Matte Finish PR
Value By Grade
1916 5c Matte Finish PR
CPG (retail) values
Currency
Grade Range
Grading Authority
Sort by
Pricing
Values
Greysheet & CPG® Values
| Grade | CAC | CPG Value (Retail) | Greysheet Price (Wholesale) |
|---|---|---|---|
| PR68 |
|
$36,000 | $1,234 |
| PR68 | - | $27,500 | $1,234 |
| PR67 |
|
$1,234 | $1,234 |
| PR67 | - | $1,234 | $1,234 |
| PR66 |
|
$1,234 | $1,234 |
| PR66 | - | $1,234 | $1,234 |
| PR65 |
|
$1,234 | $1,234 |
| PR65 | - | $1,234 | $1,234 |
| PR64 |
|
$1,234 | $1,234 |
| PR64 | - | $1,234 | $1,234 |
| PR63 |
|
$1,234 | $1,234 |
| PR63 | - | $1,234 | $1,234 |
| PR62 |
|
$1,234 | $1,234 |
| PR62 | - | $1,234 | $1,234 |
| PR61 |
|
$1,234 | $1,234 |
| PR61 | - | $1,234 | $1,234 |
| PR60 |
|
$1,234 | $1,234 |
| PR60 | - | $1,234 | $1,234 |
Buffalo Nickel 5c Type 1 Reverse, Matte Finish, 1913 PR [Type]
![Buffalo Nickel 5c Type 1 Reverse, Matte Finish, 1913 PR [Type]](https://images.greysheet.com/Ctc/CatalogEntry/ha_com_1316_3029-0.20200624004100369.jpg?MaxWidth=200&Mode=Pad&Scale=UpscaleCanvas&format=webp)
Worth: $650 – $90,000
1913 5c Buffalo, Matte Finish, Type 1 PR
Worth: $650 – $90,000
Buffalo Nickel 5c Type 2 Reverse, Matte Finish, 1913-1916 PR [Type]
![Buffalo Nickel 5c Type 2 Reverse, Matte Finish, 1913-1916 PR [Type]](https://images.greysheet.com/ProductImages/DLRC/408xxx/b38ed5b4-ab8a-41bd-befa-a7a0334ea03a.jpg?MaxWidth=200&Mode=Pad&Scale=UpscaleCanvas&format=webp)
Worth: $500 – $17,500
1913 5c Buffalo, Matte Finish, Type 2 PR
Worth: $550 – $17,500
1914 5c Matte Finish PR
Worth: $500 – $18,000
1915 5c Matte Finish PR
Worth: $600 – $225,000
1927 5c Special Strike SP
Worth: $65,000 – $78,000
Buffalo Nickel 5c Satin Finish, 1936 PR [Type]
![Buffalo Nickel 5c Satin Finish, 1936 PR [Type]](https://images.greysheet.com/ProductImages/DLRC/133xxx/378d7780-d431-4a0e-b08b-8178656221b7.jpg?MaxWidth=200&Mode=Pad&Scale=UpscaleCanvas&format=webp)
Worth: $600 – $6,000
1936 5c Satin Finish PR
Worth: $600 – $6,000
Buffalo Nickel 5c Brilliant Finish, 1936-1937 PR [Type]
![Buffalo Nickel 5c Brilliant Finish, 1936-1937 PR [Type]](https://images.greysheet.com/ctc/catalog/BuffPR.jpg?MaxWidth=200&Mode=Pad&Scale=UpscaleCanvas&format=webp)
Worth: $660 – $18,000
1936 5c Brilliant Finish PR
Worth: $735 – $8,000
1937 5c PR
Worth: $700 – $18,000
1916 5C PR64 PCGS. CAC. PCGS Population: 63 in 64, 259 finer. CAC: 6 in 64, 72 finer (11/25). CDN: $2,000 Whsle. Bid for NG...
$2,562
1916 5C JD-1, High R.2, PR66 NGC. ...
$4,148
1916 5C PR67 PCGS. CAC....
$9,900
1916 Buffalo Nickel. Proof-66 (PCGS).
$6,000
1916 5C PR65 PCGS....
$2,640
1916 Buffalo Nickel. Proof-68 (PCGS).
$22,800
1916 5C PR64 PCGS. PCGS Population: 63 in 64, 259 finer (11/25). CDN: $2,000 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS PR64. Mintage 600. ...
$4,026
1916 5C JD-1, High R.2, PR66 PCGS. ...
$5,124
1916 5C PR67 NGC. ...
$5,040
1916 Buffalo Nickel. Proof. Unc Details--Spot Removed (PCGS).
$1,140
1916 5C PR65 NGC. ...
$4,320
1916 5C PR68 PCGS. ...
$25,200
1916 Buffalo Nickel. Proof-64 (CACG).
$3,360
1916 Buffalo Nickel. JD-1. Rarity-2+. Proof-66 (PCGS).
$4,560
1916 5C PR67 PCGS. CAC. ...
$9,000
1916 Buffalo Nickel. Proof. Unc Details--Spot Removed (PCGS).
$1,440
5C 1916 PCGS PR65 CAC
$3,995
1916 5C PR68 PCGS. ...
$31,200
1916 5C PR64 NGC. NGC Census: (36/137). PCGS Population: (63/234). CDN: $2,000 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS PR64. Mintage 600. ...
$1,800
1916 5C PR66+ PCGS. CAC....
$7,200
Greysheet News
Greysheet Offers Former Numismaster Subscribers 3 Months Free Subscription
8/10/2026
Special Quarters Headed for Circulation
The search is on for special quarter dollars that will be placed in circulation by the United States Mint as part of the nation's Semiquincentennial celebration.
8/10/2026
The Business of Numismatics: August 2026 Greysheet Editor's Letter
With the month of July and all the celebrations of Independence Day behind us, the rare coin market looks with anticipation to August.
8/7/2026
Events
Heritage Auctions: US Currency Tuesday Select Auction
Location: Heritage Auctions
Tuesday, June 2, 2026
Heritage Auctions: World Paper Money Tuesday Select Auction
Location: Heritage Auctions
Tuesday, June 2, 2026
Heritage Auctions: US Coins Tuesday & Wednesday Select Auction
Location: Heritage Auctions
Wednesday, June 3, 2026